Writing a school-wide assessment policy is no easy feat. If you want a document that genuinely drives teaching and learning, you have to design a collaborative process with that goal firmly in mind. At our school, we wanted a policy that was inclusive, practical, and flexible enough to respect individual teaching styles and subject-specific practices—one that applied across all sections of the school (juniors, cadets, jeunes seniors, and seniors) while bridging our Anglophone and Francophone programmes and supporting students’ home languages.
Because our curriculum had recently undergone a thorough review—reconsidering content alongside vertical and horizontal alignment—we felt that “what we learn” was concrete enough to turn our attention to “how we learn” and “whether we learn.” Grounded in research on Assessment for Learning, we recognised that our pedagogical and assessment practices were deeply intertwined and needed to be developed in parallel.
Establishing a Working Committee: Goals and Procedures
When our 15-person committee first convened in Autumn 2022—bringing together voices from every department, school section, and roles of responsibility across the campus—we resisted the urge to start by writing rules. Instead, we began by unpacking our own beliefs about assessment.
Using a “Beliefs About Assessment” questionnaire, we quickly discovered that while our team shared core values, we held very different assumptions about how they worked in practice. Out of the entire survey, only two statements earned unanimous agreement: that designing quality assessments requires specific training, and that results should strictly reflect intended learning outcomes rather than extraneous factors such as behaviour or punctuality. Beyond those two points, the committee was evenly split on nearly every major question—largely because we had not yet distinguished between formative and summative contexts, nor agreed on a shared vocabulary.
When we reconvened later in the term to unpack those divides, our debates forced us to sharpen our thinking. For instance, when discussing whether students are the “owners” of their assessment results, we realised the term was misleading: students own their work, but teachers ultimately determine summative grades. What we actually wanted to cultivate was not grade ownership, but student agency—the capacity to respond to and act upon feedback. Likewise, rather than mandating formal diagnostic tests, self-assessments, or written feedback at every turn, we recognised the need to equip teachers with a flexible repertoire of both formal and informal habits. Ultimately, these discussions proved that before drafting any guidelines, we needed to establish precise, shared definitions.
Towards the end of term, we audited our existing documentation and conducted a SWOT analysis. While our previous policy valued teacher agency and intercultural understanding, many colleagues observed that greater precision around expectations would support more consistent professional practice (especially one that is evidence-based, research driven). More importantly, we identified clear pain points for our students:
- Lack of transparency: Students often did not know how final grades were calculated or what a specific score actually meant across different programmes.
- Inconsistency across classrooms: Students switching sets or sections of the same course encountered markedly different expectations, and similar work could receive different grades depending on how teachers interpreted criteria.
- Mixed signals on reports: Academic achievement grades, narrative comments, and Attitude and Effort marks sometimes sent contradictory messages, pointing to ambiguity in our criteria or a lack of clear expectations for report writing.
Building the Framework
Recognising that rigid “standardisation” can clash with a school culture that values creativity and professional autonomy, we aimed instead for shared principles and coherence. To bridge the gap between educational theory and daily classroom habits, we settled on a five-part structure:
- A. Key Terms: Establishing a shared, bilingual vocabulary (distinguishing between assessment and grading, scores and attainment levels, and clarifying terms such as diagnostic, formative, and summative assessments).
- B. Formative Assessment Principles: Defining purpose and suggesting classroom approaches.
- C. Summative Assessment Principles: Outlining purpose and effective design.
- D. Grading: Using summative evidence to calculate valid, meaningful grades—and clarifying equivalences across programmes.
- E. Reporting: Determining how grades are communicated and used.
We also decided that chapters should open with a Preamble outlining the overarching rationale, followed by a From Theory to Practice section offering concrete strategies to bring current research into the classroom.
Collaborative Drafting and Staff Feedback
The committee split into five trios to review the research and draft one section each. After reviewing and refining every chapter as a whole group, we presented the unified document to the school’s leadership team (Direction).
Once approved, we dedicated an entire INSET session to bringing the whole teaching staff into the conversation. Every colleague received a copy of the draft alongside a guided questionnaire asking for specific feedback on the clarity of the theoretical explanations and the practicality of the recommended strategies. We collated their responses and revised the text accordingly. At that stage, the document was shared internally, though not yet officially published. The final piece of the puzzle took a further eighteen months to complete: a comprehensive overhaul of our Attitude and Effort rubric, also drafted by a diverse group of teachers. Once this was integrated into both the policy and our reporting system, we were finally ready to publish.
Enacting the Policy—and Navigating Cultural Friction
As we noted during our planning meetings, a policy is only as good as the time invested in embedding it; without sustained follow-through, it risks becoming just another forgotten document. That is why my colleague Caroline Gralepois and I are now meeting with individual departments to help colleagues reflect on their current habits, build internal alignment, and explore how the policy applies to their specific disciplines.
The response so far has been very encouraging, with teachers praising the document’s clarity, simplicity, and balance of accessible theory with actionable guidance. At the same time, it has been fascinating to observe the spectrum of engagement: while many colleagues welcome the space to reflect and actively seek feedback to refine their practice, others are more cautious, complying with the guidelines without necessarily embracing the shift. In any whole-school initiative there is an inherent tension between building genuine buy-in—by exploring the underlying research and rationale—and taking a more directive approach. Caroline and I have worked hard to strike a thoughtful balance between the two. Encouragingly, these departmental conversations have also sparked practical, teacher-led next steps within subject teams, including shared summative cover sheets, student self-reflection templates, essential agreements on sharing learning objectives at the start of every unit, and common assessment rubrics by summative type.
Alongside this progress, however, our discussions have surfaced deeper cultural tensions. Two recurring questions stand out:
- External pressure: How do we successfully keep learning at the centre when university admissions and parental expectations push so strongly toward grades?
- Institutional incentives: How do we shift our culture toward intrinsic growth when high academic attainment is directly linked to extra privileges within our boarding school?
Many teachers feel these two dynamics actively pull against our efforts to value learning above achievement. Navigating those tensions—while protecting the time teachers need to genuinely embed new habits—will be our greatest challenge moving forward. For now, though, we are taking a moment to celebrate the official launch of the new policy with the committee and our wider school community.
Leave me a message if you would like me to email you a copy.